Home

Commens
Digital Companion to C. S. Peirce



Latest...

28/05/2018 Habit Meaning Pragmatism [R]
09/04/2018 Critic On Signs [R]
09/04/2018 Speculative Grammar On Signs [R]
09/04/2018 Methodeutic On Signs [R]
24/03/2018 Real Relation On the Logic of Quantity
24/03/2018 Truth On the Logic of Quantity
24/03/2018 Proposition On the Logic of Quantity
24/03/2018 Relation of Reason On the Logic of Quantity
24/03/2018 Philosophy On the Logic of Quantity
24/03/2018 Mathematics On the Logic of Quantity

Some Wit, Wisdom & Bewilderment

…all that logic warrants is a hope, and not a belief. It must be admitted, however, that such hopes play a considerable part in logic. For example, when we discuss a vexed question, we hope that there is some ascertainable truth about it, and that the discussion is not to go on forever and to no purpose. A transcendentalist would claim that it is an indispensable ‘presupposition’ that there is an ascertainable true answer to every intelligible question. I used to talk like that, myself; for when I was a babe in philosophy my bottle was filled from the udders of Kant. But by this time I have come to want something more substantial.
Minute Logic, c. 1902